My pal Sujith had adviced me to read this book quite a number of years ago. For one reason or another I was not able to do it (one of the reasons could be that I did pick up one of the subsequent books but found it very boring and confusing, most probably cause I was trying to read it without any context)

Frank Herberts Dune

The book is fascinating! I could not find any single idea which was revolutionary or shocking (to be fair, it is an old book and i might just be jaded with al the sci-fi we get today) but the way it was put together was really beautiful. It’s sci-fi part of the book is in fact quite interesting – especially in the idea of the whole galaxy depending upon a dry, almost inhabitable planet. his central idea iself makes this book really really good. However this alone would not make his book great.

What makes this book great is the analogies with older stories and histories. Most iconic sci-fi books are iconic because of the way they weave in the myths and histories of human life into fantastic departures from the real world. This makes them topical given any time context. Well in this case that this book is truly iconic!!!


There was not one chapter i read which did not remind me of something else. The two main things it reminded me of was:
one) The story of Lawrence of Arabia. Unmissable in the latter parts. However this was the more tivial of analogies

two) the way the protaganist’s story feels very close to Prophet Mohammed’s story is the real kicker. Unluckly I have ot read the koran or the story of Prophet Mohammed’s life. So the analogy to the beginnings of Islam is just what I know from pop history but it is an uncanny feeling one has while reading the book. And it’s great how that messanic tale has been given a new outlook here.

There were other connections I saw but these where after Dune was published. For example in Robert Jordan’s Wheel Of The World series you have the similar organisations like the Bene Gesserits. Then there is Tatooine – like Dune a desert planet.

Hopping over to the Wikipedia site for Dune I see even more connections which did not click earlier. Primary among them the allusions to the East India Company and foretelling, in a way, a powerful organisation like OPEC. And I completely missed the Aiel reference which can be found in the page “Dune in popular culture“.

Well seems I have come to the end of my page with nary a critical view of the novel. Guess you will have to live with that:D

But before going I will quote these lines which I read here:
“Frank Herbert’s 1963 Dune is to science fiction what The Lord of The Rings is to fantasy: the most popular, most influential and most critically-acclaimed novel in the genre. Herbert’s novel was a revelation: before Dune, even the most well-written science fiction had been mostly “wonderful gadget” stories, or political commentary expressed through exaggeration. It had never occurred to anyone that science fiction could offer the literary depth of Dostoevsky, the intricate “wheels within wheels” intrigues of Shakespeare or so deeply fulfill the heroic epic form behind Gilgamesh, The Odyssey, Le Morte D’Arthur, The Mahabharata, and Beowulf.”
That sums it all – the ability to use science fiction to create myth!
Thanks Sujith!


7 thoughts on “Dune

  1. There’s no doubt that Dune is one of the top books of the genre, almost precisely because of the incredible interplay of so many factors: religion, ecology, politics at several levels and in different governmental forms, philosophy, cultural anthropology, economics, and of course the entire messiah complex. But it would have been a bust without some real people to populate it, from Paul and Jessica to our dear isolated Princess. I first read it when it came out in Analog in 1963 and 1965 (it appeared as two serials, one 3 part and one 5 part, with some absolutely gorgeous cover art by Schoenherr), and was strongly captivated by it.

    In general, the sequels don’t match the power of the first book, though they do bring some even grander ideas into the mix, and the various prequels written by his son and Kevin Anderson range only from fair to atrocious.

    Whether it’s the best thing ever written in the field is up for debate, as there are several other strong contenders. But as one of the most accessible books for readers who are not familiar with SF, it’s often my first recommendation to them.

  2. Dune is good. It has to be plodded through to be enjoyed (much like book 5 of the LOTR). Nice comparison to the LoA, tho 🙂

    Brij, now its time to get started (if u have’nt already) on the collected short stories of Philip K Dick.
    It’s absolutely mind-boggling how he jumps from idea to brand-new idea with each story.
    It’s not a saga/epic and the language is not all that praise-worthy but you’ll rever him for the experience.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s